HomeХобби и стильRelated VideosMore From: The Modest Man

Brown Boots vs. Black Boots | Which Color Is Better For YOU?

1852 ratings | 121798 views
So you’ve decided to buy a new pair of boots. Maybe you’re expanding your shoe collection, or maybe this will be your first pair of boots. This video will help you pick the right color. It's brought to you in partnership with Thursday Boot Company: https://thursdayboots.com/modestman Of course, you’ll need to pick the right type of boot. If you’re not sure about white type of boot is the best choice for you, check out my video about the three best types of boots for men (link below). No matter which type of boot you settle on, you’ll need to choose a color. While there are many different colors of boots, the two most common are black and brown. Both are excellent choices for almost anyone, including guys who are buying their first pair of boots. In fact, many men have both colors in their collection. But if you could only chose one, which is the best color for you? In my opinion, there is no universal “best” choice. It all comes down to your personal preferences and situation. INSPIRATION ALBUMS: Rugged: https://imgur.com/a/3eF4J Preppy: https://imgur.com/a/EWYI1 Street: https://imgur.com/a/LeZha — SHOP THE VIDEO ▪ Black Chelseas → http://fave.co/2iA3ZT7 ▪ Brown work boots → http://fave.co/2wHpwj4 ▪ Grey t-shirt → http://fave.co/2s7JvFk ▪ Olive jacket → http://fave.co/2ka20H5 — RELATED VIDEOS ▪ 3 Best Types of Boots → https://youtu.be/0D_esMhl4yU ▪ My Shoe Collection → https://youtu.be/rztREUQ_nsU — MY GEAR ▪ Canon T6i → http://geni.us/4kSX ▪ Laptop → http://fave.co/2hgKaDF ▪ Laptop stand → http://fave.co/2vQwBj3 ▪ Lens #1 (50mm) → http://geni.us/OiE9 ▪ Lens #2 (10-18mm) → http://geni.us/qgGQckE ▪ Lens #3 (24mm) → http://geni.us/x61A ▪ Lav mic → http://geni.us/ZBlvGh ▪ Desk mic → http://geni.us/wCdS7t2 — YOUTUBE MUSIC → https://goo.gl/UhwtMb — STYLE GUIDES ▪ Free E-Books → http://mdst.mn/guide-pack ▪ Premium Guide → http://mdst.mn/tmmsg — FOLLOW ME ▪ Podcast → http://fave.co/2vej94M ▪ Instagram → https://www.instagram.com/modestmanstyle/ ▪ Twitter → https://twitter.com/modestmanstyle ▪ Facebook → https://www.facebook.com/modestmanblog/ ▪ Private Group → https://www.facebook.com/groups/modestmen — Contains affiliate links // Stay stylish!
Html code for embedding videos on your blog
Text Comments (235)
Łukasz lukasss (11 days ago)
evrybody today say "hay no black on casual shoes" only for formal occasions. I say NO! Now evrybody walk with brown shoes. And colour dont make your loafers or derby shoes formal . Black looks so good with denim and give this a little higher style to the casual look. I like brown , burgundy but this stupid rules no brown in town or black=formal i hate this
ziggyplay (15 days ago)
horrible chelsea boots style, you should go for the classic design with a very thin shoe sole.
The Modest Man (15 days ago)
You should go for that style IF you want that style. It’s totally subjective. Lots of guys are wearing Chelseas more casually these days.
Filu Carcamo (17 days ago)
Why not both?
67spankadelik (25 days ago)
I would think buy what you need now and get the other later. Not having both is a limit on what you can wear.
woodstock (29 days ago)
hey are those the higgins mill chromexcel? 0:23
CaliforniaLove 818 (1 month ago)
Brown !!!
Jeremy Harris (1 month ago)
Black for formal, brown for casual.
Richard - (1 month ago)
one is formal. one is informal. get both and work it out
blackopssavage (1 month ago)
Copped a pair of brown scout boots from Thursday Boot company but found that they run a little too big. Go 1 and a half size smaller than normally.
Doroteo Garcia (1 month ago)
Brown boots look better in the day and Black boots look better at night.
Doroteo Garcia (1 month ago)
Brown boots wear them in the day and Black boots wear them at night.
dragomxsoldier (1 month ago)
Thanks for the info, very helpful
WWIIRebel (1 month ago)
I have a bad habit of wearing outdated clothing styles that reflect like i stepped out of the 1930-40's,lol. With anything like a grey suit coat and matching trousers, i wear brown boots or shoes with that style and a matching color fedora,lol. Otherwise ,when i wear actual jeans and a t shirt i wear either black or brown boots, so it kinda varies, depending on the function i'm attending.When i wear desert boots i wear thesehttp://onlinemilitaria.net/products/3427-UK-Desert-Boots/ . I have two pairs , with which i dyed one pair brown, the other black. Anyone could also just leave em as they are (grey-ish) in color and go with that too.
Naokatsu (1 month ago)
Brown is for casual wear. So always wear brown shoes unless you want to be formal. Thats how I been taught
Wich app or page you use to look those outfits ? Its like pinterest or something?
+The Modest Man thanks !!
The Modest Man (1 month ago)
Francisco Oyarzo Casanello those albums live on Imgur, and they were put together by reddit MFA users (links in description).
Ambiance (1 month ago)
i think black boots look more dressy especially with chelsea boots. so i like brown boots more because you can both dress them up and dress them down
Angel Ponce (1 month ago)
A question to help all the small, slim footed gentlemen! It’s extremely difficult to find good boots that fit and don’t look feminine (not that there’s anything wrong with that.) Is there a boot company that runs smaller? I’m about a 6 to 6.5 in boots it seems, and most places don’t carry under 7 or even 8! Is there hope???
JamesDelta (1 month ago)
What jacket are you wearing in this video?
JamesDelta (1 month ago)
Thanks. Great videos!
The Modest Man (1 month ago)
JamesDelta this is the Peter Manning Tribeca field jacket in olive (size 1). One of my all time favorites!
C.E. Parks (1 month ago)
I know I'm late to the party, but black shoes are FORMAL. If you wear them otherwise, fine, but you are wearing them incorrectly.
The Modest Man (1 month ago)
C.E. Parks if you’re talking about dress shoes like Oxfords, I agree. But boots and sneakers aren’t necessarily formal, even if they’re black.
Jacquelyn (1 month ago)
Clicked on the video because those black Chelsea boots are stunning
Supreme Brick (2 months ago)
Just waiting to be able to afford them.
Violent Immortal (2 months ago)
I could never get a pair of Chelsea boots they're so girly and gross
Me Too (2 months ago)
Hey Brock, I have a question. I own a pair of dark brown cap toe boots but I think they are more dressy with a slimmer profile than the Thursday’s Boot you have. Could I use my “dressier” boots in a more casual way the same way I would with a more rugged looking Thursday boot? I would like to use them to achieve a casual rugged look with them. I bought my pair so that they could be more versatile. What do you think?
Molly O'Brien (2 months ago)
personal style journey, fuck off
The Modest Man (2 months ago)
Thought you were leaving?! Thanks for the views 😉
Joe Asuncion (2 months ago)
Brown and Black.
Internet Comment (2 months ago)
This video is stupid af. Both colors are for everyone
The Modest Man (2 months ago)
Thanks for your contribution.
Ron (4 months ago)
black boots <3
aerotonix (4 months ago)
What jacket are you wearing in this video?
AyyGin (5 months ago)
Is every men's style channel sponsored by Thursday lol
Underskjær Productions (5 months ago)
I have a black feline-buckle guccibelt so I think my best choice is to pair them with black chelsea boots, a nice black leatherjacket and some darkwashed jeans. I think the black one's are more badass and should only go with other black leather clothing. I think I'll buy some cognac monk-straps as my brown dressy shoes. Then, if I like them I'll get some brown boots too.
Javier Fernandez (6 months ago)
I preffer Brown,because this color on particular get differents tones,that combine And Match whith pants ,all chinos colors,,chocolate,dark brown,soft brown,honey Brown,caramel brown,coñac,brandy,Middle brown,coffee,etc..You get a lot posibilities to dress any outfit.
Javier Fernandez (6 months ago)
Brock,You get a tour video of Your shoe collection?,and What shoe collection do you like from others ,thankyou!!
Kriss Kross (6 months ago)
the brown boots don't look brown to me, but reddish.
FrazzerM (6 months ago)
I am that 14 year old that prefers boots more than the Nike and Yeezys
José Apolinar (6 months ago)
At minute 0:23, what is that pair of shoe at the far left called? Any links? I'm not sure why you put it next to the two boots because I initially thought they were boat shoes but are they just brown leather sneakers?
The Modest Man (6 months ago)
That is a camp moccasin (also called a voucher moc). It’s like a boat shoe that you can wear with socks. Best suited for fall and winter but it can definitely be a year round shoe, and you can wear it sockless since it’s fully leather lined. This particular one is from LL Bean.
Julien Etherion (6 months ago)
brown Corcoran jump boots are the best footwear I've ever own !
Darkus Hydranoid (7 months ago)
I'm in the UK and here where I live at least, I really only see like 80% streetware and 20% rugged haha The new world And then here I am trying to look like I'm from the 17th Century with a white dress shirt, black leathers and black overcoat x)
Birki gts (7 months ago)
I own both but i tend to wear my black boots more often, it just suits my casual style better. Brown for me is more reserved to dressing up a bit, a date, interview, etc.
Tuyen Hoang (7 months ago)
Who wear black leather boots or shoes anymore. Brown looks way better
Tuyen Hoang (7 months ago)
Chris Lim shits nobody said
Chris Lim (7 months ago)
Tuyen Hoang BLACK LEATHERS ARE WAY MORE POPULAR, WAY MORE BAD ASS, WAY MORE COOLER, WAY MORE EDGIER, WAY MORE MANLY, WAY MORE VERSATILE(CASUAL OR DRESSY)... ANY DUDE WHO DOES NOT HAVE A SINGLE BLACK LEATHER CLOTHING IS NOT NORMAL!
donkeyenvious (7 months ago)
What is your shoe size?
The Modest Man (7 months ago)
7 US
Andy1119 (7 months ago)
I go with a pair of brown chelsea boots with a pair of lightwash jeans usually. Looks okay
Rex Erection (7 months ago)
Depends. How formal do you want to be?
James H (7 months ago)
The difference between brown boots and black boots is the colour.
tat8johny (7 months ago)
I think that brown boots are for the daytime and black for the night.
ConRon (7 months ago)
That’s hard. Black goes with nearly everything and is a little dressier but brown is nice and casual. I have both
Chris Lim (6 months ago)
BLACK LEATHER will NEVER go out in fashion. Yea.
ConRon (7 months ago)
Chris Lim I’m aware, but when the item is identical, Black will always be more dressier. The “dressiest” situation you can be in is black tie, which requires black.
Chris Lim (7 months ago)
ConRon Black leather can be casual or dressy.
tom jens (7 months ago)
there is a nice infogram on the internet, where it is shown that brown shoes fit with every color pants except black. Black shoes do not fit with more than just one color pants. Brown is a no braner for those that do not like black pants :)
Decaf McLatte (7 months ago)
Whoa. I wasn’t expecting much from this video besides pandering but you brought up some insightful points and put a lot of work and care into this. Respect. Subscribed.
Mad Hatter (8 months ago)
You can see more details in a brown boot plus there are more shades in brown.
wayal ak manba (8 months ago)
Thanks for the video. By the way, what's the title of the jazz music in the beginning of the video? Let me know. Thx
Rusty Shackleford (8 months ago)
Brown ages very well, black really doesn't show much age. Overall dark brown is a much more versatile boot.
Jaynern Abideen (8 months ago)
Brown boot is better. its ageing beautifully create its own character.
Givi Karbelashvili (8 months ago)
Hey Brock, what other brands would you recommend for black Chelsea boots besides Thursday Boot Co? I'm thinking of Allen Edmonds Liverpools. Any suggestions? Thanks:)
joshpembers (8 months ago)
What about width sizing?  With my New Balance athletic shoes or my more Dress shoes, I order 2E with ((and the Thursday boots only come with a D medium width.  Do I need to order a size larger?  Or do I need to find boots from a different manufacturer. I really like several of the boots available from Thursday ... but not sure they will work out??  I suppose they would take a "return" if sent back right away...or maybe not?   Any suggestions?  Thank you, Ron.
LouisL1963 (8 months ago)
Got three different colours - Brown, Tan, and Black :-)
pebre79 (8 months ago)
Great practical advice and no-nonsense explanation.
Hayden Eden (8 months ago)
I like the Balenciaga SSS
Hayden Eden (8 months ago)
Why is this even a thing, just get fly
Sonali Biswal (8 months ago)
brown is good
Nicholas Ramirez (8 months ago)
BOTH spice it up and make different dapper outfits. Don’t limit yourself
Thursday Boot Company (8 months ago)
We agree :)
Matthew (9 months ago)
I am so conflicted, I love my Navy and black bottoms but love my pastel/white tops. Probably will go for black as it works slightly more often.
Matthew (9 months ago)
What do you think on black clothes on paler guys? I am probs about the same as you tone wise.
Music is the bomb (9 months ago)
What type of boots should I buy if my clothes is Extremely casual?
The Modest Man (9 months ago)
Work boots 👍🏻
The Uncanny Aviator (9 months ago)
Great insights...
Vibez 123 (9 months ago)
Great channel. I love your collection of Peter manning
robo931 (9 months ago)
All of your videos should have more views. But then again, most guys look like crap and don't care about their attire which is unfortunate.
Daniel Anchondo (9 months ago)
I highly prefer brown but require at least 1 black pair of shoes/boots that fit the army regs because of the army.
Mami Burger (9 months ago)
I saw on instagram that you liked the business "trendy butler". I like the concept behind that business, but I stay away from these kind of businesses since, well, I'm short. I doubt a stylist will be able to send something that will fit me, and I don't think they will tailor anything specifically for me since there is a chance I will return it. What are your thoughts on businesses like trendy butler? Do you recommend I try them out? Do you have any other suggestions of similar companies that work for short guys? I'm your size and dimensions except a few inches shorter.
Rev. James C (9 months ago)
After spending a small fortune on boots and shoes this past year, I realise that I don’t have a single pair of black footwear.
Rev. James C (7 months ago)
Chris, Be calm. I actually did have a pair of black Dr Martens when writing the above comment. But they are more of a work boot. Since then I purchased a nice pair of Church’s cap-toe shoes, the Consul. So I’m officially normal. 😉
Chris Lim (7 months ago)
Rev. James C Buy at least a dozen pairs of black leather ones, dude! A dude that has no black leather clothing is not normal.
MrDikembeMutombo (9 months ago)
Could you tell me what moc toe shoes those are to the left of the Thursday boots? Thanks!!
K H (9 months ago)
like the idea of the INSPIRATION ALBUMS! thanks for sharing!
markyhundreds (9 months ago)
hook it up with some Captain Terracottas!
Tam Nguyen (9 months ago)
Hi Broc, could you please share you MTM measurements on your suits? I have a similar build to yours. Thank you.
Brian Tac-an-Fonteneau (9 months ago)
Hey Big Up From France 👍😉 What about The size Of The Shoes??they have The Same fit or What?
Steve Steele (9 months ago)
Kinda looks like someone stole your pictures
The Modest Man (9 months ago)
Ah I get it. Those are actually sound dampening panels. They're kind of like thin cloth squares.
Steve Steele (9 months ago)
The Modest Man the pictures on your wall kinda look like a imprint of where pictures used to be. Like the sun faded the wall and you too the picture off leaving the imprint.
The Modest Man (9 months ago)
?
iPulse Leather (9 months ago)
Love cognac shoes. Merry Christmas, Man
Anónimo (9 months ago)
Can you help me and my skinny fellas out there to find the right clothe? Can you do a video please
The Modest Man (9 months ago)
I'm pretty thin myself (under 120 lbs), so anything you see me wearing should work okay for you.
D Bar (9 months ago)
I'd go with brown boots. They are very versatile and can go well with almost anything (compared to black boots). But I would also throw in a pair of burgundy/oxblood boots - just for a fun twist.
Anthony Vo (9 months ago)
Should I buy black Chelsea boots if I’m in highschool, I don’t know if that is appropriate for my age being a junior in highschool.
Chris Lim (7 months ago)
Anthony Vo Yea.
Stuart Woodward (9 months ago)
Notice you gravitate towards rubber sole over leather. Is there a reason for that?
The Modest Man (9 months ago)
It’s nice for rainy/winter conditions.
saleem waheed (10 months ago)
You gotta have both!
Adrian Ortega (10 months ago)
Did you get the same size in both those boots or do they have a different sizing ,
The Modest Man (10 months ago)
Same size 👍🏻
Akshay Kawale (10 months ago)
Is the leather jacket at 4:05 Peter Manning?
Akshay Kawale (10 months ago)
Brock, I'm glad you seem to actually be using the products you promote. I actually own one in Brown myself. :-)
The Modest Man (10 months ago)
Yes sir! Here's a full review if you haven't seen it - https://www.themodestman.com/peter-manning-leather-jacket-review/
N Lin (10 months ago)
So black boots go with navy even though they're similar colors?
The Modest Man (10 months ago)
Yes, black shoes go well with navy suits and trousers. For example, a dark navy suit with sleek black Chelsea boots = very dapper.
J (10 months ago)
Dude. You need to come to Thailand. American chicks are dumb i.e. Whitney Cummings. It hurts seeing the pain on your face. You're a good guy.
The Modest Man (10 months ago)
You sure you're on the right video??
Alex Dc (10 months ago)
Great vid. I think I made the mistake with my shoes selection by watching a lot of other videos and vlogs from other YouTubers. Boots usually give you a little more room to play because they also have a purpose during winter.
Pyridius (10 months ago)
Another great video! I find your videos are consistently high quality and they're done very well. The editing is nice and simple and doesn't always have a list format.
The Modest Man (10 months ago)
Thank you! I'm trying to keep it straightforward, no hype and easy to watch.
Myrslokstok (10 months ago)
They should be a bit moore dressy, lightbrown, medium brown or dark brown, is a very nice first pair. Would not go tan brown. 1) Works better at spring and "summer". 2) Get a nice patina with age. 3) Deeper dept in full grain lether. 4) But go kind of dressy with brown. But agree otherwise, you are kind of right again.
Arthur Doctolero (10 months ago)
My style I'm developing is kinda schizophrenic. I wear brown shoes when I'm wearing Oxford shirts, poloshirts, and chinos at work. I wear black boots when I wear my "rocker" look on weekends.
Chris Lim (7 months ago)
Arthur Doctolero You should rock more often.
050156jg (10 months ago)
Both appeal to me. However, I would like to know if a pair of side zip pair of boots (Chelsea boot height) in my collection are still in style? Or should I retire them? Please get back to me with your opinion. Thanks.
Eduardo Aray (10 months ago)
The inspiration albums are a nice touch. Thanks!
Sahil Kumar (10 months ago)
you are the best , excellent superb, outstanding, magnificent, of high quality, of the highest quality, of the highest standard, exceptional, marvellous, wonderful, sublime, perfect, eminent, pre-eminent, matchless, peerless, supreme, first-rate, first-class, superlative, splendid, admirable, worthy, sterling, fine and awesome video!
Trevor Sebastian (10 months ago)
I like black, maybe I'm just younger so I like that edgier look, I do wear a lot of black like black jeans and black jackets too hah
Mr Dobalina (2 days ago)
I have no idea what you guys mean when you say “edgy”.
Chris Lim (7 months ago)
Trevor Sebastian Black leather is the way to go! It goes well with anything. It is versatile, cool, bad ass, manly, edgy and hot as well. I'm a black leather cladded dude all the way. Personally, I think ALL dudes should wear black leather and make shit color leather extinct. They represent real bad fashion sense in a dude.
Corey Saunders (10 months ago)
Not a fan of black leather shoes, brown is so versatile these days it's hard to find an excuse to wear black for me. Unless I'm wearing an all black suit and/or dressed for an event I always reach for a cognac brown or suede book/oxford/loafer.
Zawadi Shop (8 months ago)
Corey Saunders definitely brown, makes other colors pop.
RacksonRacksonRibss (8 months ago)
You don't have to wear black shoes with blue suit to look good lol. If you don't want the extreme contrast of light brown/tan go for dark brown or eggplant, like a color8. Still looks very classy without the 'WHAT ARE THOSE?' contrast. ...I have noticed a lot of guys pairing blue suits with light brown/tan shoes, and agree with @Duke Of Prunes in that it's getting old. Especially when they're clearly some cheap, glued sole shoes.
Duke Of Prunes (8 months ago)
Corey Saunders There is no point in dressing up if you do it poorly. That said, I am sorry for being rude. I get a bit carried away when discussing shoes.
Corey Saunders (8 months ago)
Wow these comments are unnecessarily rude. Come on fellas hopefully we are all grown here, let's act like it.
Duke Of Prunes (8 months ago)
Corey Saunders Brown shoes with a blue suit look like you are either trying to draw attention to your shoes (why?), or maybe you do not have a wife to set out your clothes every night? Stop being a cheap-ass and buy some goddamn BLACK shoes, already.
yves florendo (10 months ago)
what's the brand of the dark blue suede boots?
The Modest Man (10 months ago)
Thursday Boot Company
James Harris (10 months ago)
Great video!
Sakib Alam (10 months ago)
Love your videos my man. I am always inspired by your style!!! more videos pls 🙏🏻
Ethan Woodbury (10 months ago)
Nice video! Just bought a pair of dark brown chukas and wear them all the time now.
Daniel Escobedo (10 months ago)
Brown is The best
linkinparkroxx (10 months ago)
Good video as usual - but please don't use emojis
The Modest Man (10 months ago)
👏👏👏 haha well played!
linkinparkroxx (10 months ago)
Better idea: Create a video using nothing BUT emojis!
The Modest Man (10 months ago)
😀 ... 😔
Christian Inzunza (10 months ago)
My friend last weekend I bought my first pair, thankfully i made the right choice and went for black, excellent video 👍

Would you like to comment?

Join YouTube for a free account, or sign in if you are already a member.